Doors & Deeds Real Estatebrokered by eXp Realty · 352-833-7672
Home → Communities → Sumter County → Middleton

Middleton — Middleton, Sumter County, Florida

Middleton is a platted community in Middleton, Sumter County, Florida — 1,859 lots in ZIP 34762, with 961 homes built and roughly 900 lots still unbuilt. Homes here have been going up since 2023; the median home was built in 2024. 961 homes date from 2020 or later.

Middleton facts — from county records

Parcels (lots)1,859, across 25 recorded plats
Homes built961 — the remaining ~900 parcels are lots with no home built yet
Years homes were built2023–2025 · median year built 2024 · 961 homes built 2020 or later
Typical lot sizeMedian 0.15 acres · middle half of measured lots run 0.13–0.18 acres (county land records carry a square-foot measurement for 1,859 of this community's lots; converted to acres)
Typical home sizeMedian 2,218 sq ft (county total living-area figure for the home)
SchoolsAssignment is by exact address — confirm yours with the Sumter County School District

County records as of Oct 2, 2026. Source: Sumter County Property Appraiser records (Florida Dept. of Revenue 2026 final tax-roll files).

Middleton market numbers

Last 90 days

49 homes sold
Median $308,700 · range $203,300–$961,900

8 lots sold
Median $274,200 · range $207,300–$463,900

Last 12 months

185 homes sold
Median $379,500 · range $175,000–$995,900

102 lots sold
Median $320,750 · range $206,400–$921,600

Qualified (arm's-length) sales only, homes and lots counted separately. Windows: July–September 2026 (last 90 days) and October 2025–September 2026 (last 12 months) — the state sales file records month and year only, and its final month (September 2026) is partial: 39 qualified sales county-wide, against 625–867 in each full month before it. Source: Sumter County Property Appraiser records (Florida Dept. of Revenue 2026 final tax-roll files), dated Oct 2, 2026.

That's 57 sales in 90 days — homes and lots counted separately, the way the county records them.

Questions people ask about Middleton

Where is Middleton located?

Middleton is in Middleton, Florida, in Sumter County — ZIP 34762. It covers 1,859 lots across 25 recorded plats.

How big is Middleton?

Middleton covers 1,859 parcels across 25 recorded plats. 961 homes have been built, and roughly 900 lots are still unbuilt, per Sumter County Property Appraiser records (Florida Dept. of Revenue 2026 final tax-roll files) dated Oct 2, 2026.

What do homes in Middleton typically sell for?

In the 90 days recorded through September 2026 (July–September 2026), 49 homes sold at a median price of $308,700 in Middleton. Vacant lots are a separate market: in the same window, 8 lots sold at a median price of $274,200. Over the last 12 months, 185 homes sold at a median price of $379,500 and 102 lots sold at a median price of $320,750.

How active is the Middleton market?

Middleton recorded 57 qualified sales in the 90 days through September 2026 — 49 homes and 8 lots. Over the last 12 months there were 287 qualified sales, per Sumter County Property Appraiser records (Florida Dept. of Revenue 2026 final tax-roll files).

What schools serve Middleton?

School assignments for Middleton are set by the Sumter County School District by exact address, and zones change as the district grows. Confirm your address with the district before you buy — no school list is published here until it can be verified address by address.

Who is the realtor for Middleton?

Arthur "A.K." Lovarco, REALTOR® with Doors & Deeds Real Estate, brokered by eXp Realty, serves Middleton and the wider 17-county Central Florida area. Call or text 352-833-7672.

Your Middleton realtor

PHOTO
A.K. Lovarco
(drops in at publish)

Arthur "A.K." Lovarco, REALTOR®

Doors & Deeds Real Estate, brokered by eXp Realty

Marine veteran · Ocala-based · serving 17 Central Florida counties

21 closed sales · $5.1M in volume · 5.0★ on Google · 5.0★ on Realtor.com

Call or text: 352-833-7672

Work with A.K. in Middleton

Get new Middleton listings first

New listings and price drops in Middleton, sent as they hit — before the portals pass them around.

What's my Middleton home worth?

A real market analysis of your home from A.K. — built from county records and current sales, not an automated guess.

Need to sell fast? If the situation calls for it, A.K. also buys for cash — houses and land. Start a cash-offer conversation →